All his life, Archie aspired to be like his three older brothers who were successful high school and collegiate football players. He grew up the fourth of eight children. His father worked three jobs to support the family, and his mother had the tremendous responsibility of running the household.
Desire, dedication and determination are three words often associated with Archie. When he was 12 years old and playing little league football, Archie found himself over the 135-pound weight limit of the league. Rather than quit football until high school, Archie began a weight loss program, albeit, a slightly unconventional one. He converted the bathroom into a sauna, turning on all the hot water, and doing jumping jacks in the steam. He also worked up a good sweat by wearing plastic dry cleaning bags under his clothes when he ran or played basketball. He lost weight, continued playing football, and made the league's all-star team.
When he reached high school, Archie wondered what it would take for him to start on the varsity team, and he posed the question to then Eastmoor High School varsity football Coach Bob Stuart. The coach told Archie if he kept working hard, he would share playing time with a senior player–which is exactly what happened Archie's sophomore year. Archie developed into an outstanding player. He made the All-City and All-District Teams his junior and senior years and was named to the Sunkist All-American Team his senior year. His playing skills caught the attention of several college coaches, including legendary Ohio State football coach, Woody Hayes. Archie reflected, "Coach Hayes cared about people. I remember the first time I had dinner with him during the recruiting process.”
“He didn't once mention football. When I went home that evening, I told my father what had happened and how puzzled and disappointed I was. I figured Coach wasn't interested in me. My father put it all in perspective by saying, 'Don't you think he is concerned about you as a person, and not just as someone who is going to get out on the field and run for a lot of yards or score touchdowns for him?'" In the fall of 1972, Archie enrolled in The Ohio State University.