Contact Us

Add or change your insurance coverage

Please contact your independent Motorists Mutual agent. You may

use the convenient Agent Locator feature on the right side of this page.

Motorists Mutual Customer Service
For information about your Motorists policy, including billing, policy status or to obtain ID cards: 800-876-6642
Claims Service Center
To report a claim or to check on a claim's status: 800-876-8766
Claims Service Center's toll-free fax number: 800-365-2562
Claims branch addresses
3532 Massillon Road
Uniontown, OH 44685
11250 Reed Hartman Highway
Cincinnati, OH 45241
28111 Lorain Road
North Olmsted, OH 44070
Columbus: MIG Headquarters
471 East Broad Street
Columbus, OH 43215
8255 Yankee Street
Dayton, OH 45458
2674 Monroeville Boulevard
Monroeville, PA 15146


Submit your questions or comments

Use this form to contact our home office with questions about your policy or our products and services.

Please tell us how we may help you and the best way to contact you.