Motorists Mutual Insurance Company logo

 

 

 

Choose the payment option that's right for you

 

Motorists makes it easy to pay your premium by offering several convenient options—from immediate, one-time credit card payments to our EFT Program that automatically deducts premium payments from your checking account or your savings account.


Make an online payment now
Payments for personal insurance policies and commercial insurance policies can be made with a one-time credit card, debit card or checking account payment.
Commercial lines insurance policy down payments are also accepted. Click here to proceed to the online payment screen.

  

Pay by phone with 24/7 access
Call 800-611-9928 to reach our automated interactive voice response system to make a payment over the phone using your credit card, debit card or your checking account. We accept Visa, MasterCard® and Discover® Card.

 

Sign up for the convenience of EFT (personal insurance policies only)

Save those stamps and enroll in EFT (electronic funds transfer) by downloading a copy of the EFT enrollment form here. Complete the form and then send it to your independent Motorists agent to get started. Available for personal insurance policies only.

 

Make recurring payments automatically using your credit card (personal insurance policies only)
Have your premium payments automatically applied to your credit card or your debit card. We accept Visa, MasterCard® and Discover® Card.
Sign up online for recurring credit card payments here. Available for personal insurance policies only.

 

 

Mail your payment to:

The Motorists Insurance Group
PO Box 182155
Columbus, Ohio 43218